Can We Replace a 110/220 Turns Transformer with 10/20 Turns?

Can We Replace a 110/220 Turns Transformer with 10/20 Turns? . Transformers are integral to modern electrical systems, playing a vital role in voltage regulation, power distribution, and signal transmission. A common question in the field is: “Can we replace a 110/220 turns transformer with 10/20 turns?” This article examines this query in detail, breaking down the science of transformers, the implications of turns ratio, and practical considerations.

What Are Transformers?

A transformer is an electrical device that transfers electrical energy between two or more circuits through electromagnetic induction. It typically comprises:

• Primary winding: Receives the input voltage.
• Secondary winding: Delivers the transformed voltage.
• Core: Facilitates the magnetic coupling between the windings.

Read More : Maintenance of Transformer

1:2 Turn Ratio for 110:220? The Turn Ratio is Same, Shall its Rating be Same?

A step up transformer which has 110/220 turns. Can we replace it with 10/20 turns or 1:2? Turns ratio is same, shall its rating be same? Give appropriate reasons?

No. Because we know that flux is directly proportional to the ampere turns (Φ ∝ At). So if we reduce the number of turns i.e. turns ratio, flux will be also reduced which leads to reduce the induced EMF because EMF is directly proportional to the flux (EMF ∝ Φ). If we go about the transformation formula, the calculated value may be right but if we use the EMF equation of the transformer, it shows a different story. Let’s see what happens when we reduce the number of turns in the transformer windings.

Transformer Rating and Parameters

• N₁ = 110 Turns
• N₂ = 220 Turns
• E₁ = 220V
• Flux = Φ_m = 9.01 mW (mille Weber)
• E₂ = ?

Read More : Power Transformer Protection and Faults

When Turn Ratio is 110/220

To find E₂, we know that

E₂/E₁ = N₂/N₁

E₂ = (N₂/N₁) x E₁

Putting the values

E₂ = (220/110) x 220V

E₂ = 440V

When Turn Ratio is 10/20

Now, if we use 10/20 Turns ratio instead of 110/220.

E₂ = (N₂/N₁) x V1

E₂ = (20/10) x 220V

E₂ = 440V

Read More : Difference Between Single Phase and Three Phase Transformer

We can see that the value of step up voltage is same in both case whether we use 10/20 or 110/220 turns.

But I’m lying. It’s not true.

Let’s turn around to the EMF equation of the transformer.

E₁ = 4.44 x f x N₁ Φ_{m ……….. (Primary)}

E₂ = 4.44 x f N₂ Φ_{m ……….(Secondary)}

In case of turn ratio of 110/220

E₁ = 4.44 x 50 x 110 x 9.01 mW 

E₁ = 220V

E₂ = 4.44 x 50 x 220 x 9.01 mW 

E₂ = 440V

In case of turn ratio of 10/20

E₁ = 4.44 x 50 x 10 x 9.01 mW 

E₁ = 20V

E₂ = 4.44 x 50 x 20 x 9.01 mW 

E₂ = 40V

Read More : What Are the Cooling Methods of a Transformer?

That is a huge different. That’s why we can’t use 10/20 turns ratio instead of 110/220 because flux is directly proportional to the ampere turns (Φ ∝ At). If we reduce the number of turns (turns ratio of the transformer), the amount of produced flux will be reduced because of lower ampere turns which causes to reduce the amount of inducted EMF too i.e. induced EMF is directly proportional to the flux (Φ ∝ EMF).

In short, If we reduce the turn ratio of a transformer from 110/220 to 10/20 or 1:2, The following may occurs.

• The current in the primary winding of the transformer may increase due to reduced amount of impedance (Z) and resistance (R) i.e. low turns means low inductive reactance (X_L) where X_L dependents on the inductance of the turns.
• There may be high power loss due to high current in the primary as well as high power loss (I²R) which may leads to burn the primary windings of the transform.
• The induced EMF will be reduces as well due to low magnetic flux which depends on the number of coil turns.

Why Turn Count Matters in Transformer Design

Core Saturation

Transformer cores are designed to operate within specific magnetic flux limits. Replacing a 110/220 turns transformer with a 10/20 turns model increases flux density, causing potential overheating and efficiency loss.

Impedance Matching

Impedance is crucial for transformer efficiency and load handling. A 10/20 turns transformer may not match the impedance of a 110/220 turns system, leading to performance issues.

Thermal Management

High currents in a low-turn transformer generate more heat, necessitating robust thermal management to prevent failure.

Read More : Advantages of a Three-Phase Transformer Over a Single-Phase

Applications and Limitations

Applications of Low-Turn Transformers

Low-turn transformers are useful for:

• High-current, low-voltage applications (e.g., welding machines).
• Specialized circuits with specific design constraints.

Limitations

They are unsuitable for high-voltage applications or systems requiring precise voltage regulation.

Good to Know

• Transformer ratio of 2:1 is not the same as 1:2.
• Transformer turn ratio of 2:1 means this is a step down transformer.
• similarly, turn ratio of 1:2 shows a step up transformer.
• Turn ratio of 2:1 indicate that there are two turns in the transformer primary for the single turn in the secondary winding.
• In addition, turn ratio of 1:2 shows that if there are 1V in the primary, the voltage in the secondary would be 2V.
• Flux is directly proportional to the Ampere-Turns (At), not proportional to the turns ratio (N).
• In a 2:1 transformer ratio, if the current in the primary is 2A and 1A in the secondary, we are having 2 ampere turns (At) in the primary and 1 At in the secondary.
• Flux in the Primary and Secondary Winding of a transformer is always same.
• Transformer does not change the value of power, frequency, flux but only and only step up or step down the level of AC voltage or current (i.e. transformer won’t operate on DC).
• In short, if we reduce the number of turns (i.e. replacing 110/220 with 10/20), there will be insufficient flux in the core of transformer which will not work according to the rated parameters and design.

Read More : What Is an Ideal Transformer?

FAQs About Transformer Replacement

1. Can a 10/20 turns transformer handle the same power as a 110/220 turns transformer?

Not necessarily. While the turns ratio is the same, power handling depends on core size, wire gauge, and thermal capacity.

2. What happens if the core saturates?

Core saturation leads to overheating, distorted voltage output, and potential transformer failure.

3. Can frequency adjustments compensate for fewer turns?

Higher frequencies can reduce core size requirements but necessitate specialized materials and designs.

4. Is it cost-effective to replace a high-turn transformer with a low-turn model?

Typically, no. Low-turn transformers often require costlier materials and result in inefficiencies.

5. Are low-turn transformers safer?

Not inherently. They require precise design to ensure safety and reliability.

Related Topics

• Is it Possible to Operate a 50Hz Transformer on 5Hz or 500Hz Frequency?

• Which Transformer is Better: 50Hz vs 60Hz?

• What is the Fire Protection System of Transformer?

• Types of Transformers and Their Applications: The Ultimate Guide

• What Are the Uses and Applications of Transformers?

• Can We Operate a 60Hz Transformer on a 50Hz Supply Source? Everything You Need to Know

• What Is a Current Transformer (CT)? A Complete Guide to Understanding CTs in Electrical Systems

• What Is the Difference Between Current Transformer and Potential Transformer? – A Comprehensive Guide

• What is a Silica Gel Breather in Transformers? The Ultimate Guide to Protecting Transformer Performance

• Why Is the Star-Delta Connection Used in Transformers? Uncover the Benefits, Applications & Detailed Working Mechanism